Till We Meet Again

Till We Meet Again
Chloe Misseldine and Joe Won Ann in Have We Met?! Photo: Steven Pisano.

“Have We Met?!,” “Serenade after Plato’s Symposium,” “Theme and Variations”
American Ballet Theatre
David H. Koch Theater
New York, NY
October 30, 2025


For one of the final programs of its fall season, American Ballet Theatre presented a study in contrasts: the world premiere of Juliano Nunes's "Have We Met?!" explored parallel love stories across a century, while George Balanchine's "Theme and Variations" reminded us what timeless classicism looks like. Sandwiched between them, Alexei Ratmansky's 2016 "Serenade after Plato's Symposium" offered seven men in conversation – though about what, exactly, remained frustratingly unclear.

Nunes's new work, set to Luke Howard's evocative original score, opened in 1928 beneath the Manhattan Bridge (created by fringe decorations dangling above the stage), presenting the characters of Rose and Julian. They meet in a simple but effective moment: walking toward each other from the opposite wings, they pass, then turn back, anchoring their connection with a glance. Chloe Misseldine in the role of Rose embodied a 1920s beauty with a rich inner world and endless elegance, though she is not given any concrete biographical background. That weight was fully on Joo Won Anh as Julian – a Great War veteran haunted by trauma, finding salvation in Rose's presence. Misseldine’s movement maturity was likely the reason why this plotline felt authentic – her every step brought calm and reassurance, with that serenity flowing through the many leans into arabesques as Ahn twisted her into dips and embraces, even as a crowd of corps dancers would surround then. Eventually, the choreography became redundant, as if Nunes couldn’t stop repeating one perfect phrase that captured all the points he tried to make. Only the menacing corps swarming around the leads provided contrast.   

That’s where the ballet first stumbled in earnest. The ensemble moved with jerky, angular gestures – bent elbows yanking awkwardly, spastic lunges that bordered on the cartoonish – at times evoking Disney's 1929 "Skeleton Dance" more than period expressionism. They pulled at Ahn as he clutched his head in anguish, pursuing him relentlessly but never approaching Misseldine. Why? The thematic logic remained unclear, unless they were but Julian’s intrusive thoughts. But then, she had such warmth and pull, how could she not bring full salvation? A tortured solo finally showed Julian's loss of control, the section ending with his death and her collapse.

The scene then reset in 2038, this time with Isabella Boylston and Joseph Markey as the leads under the (still fringed) Brooklyn Bridge.  They did get names – Orion and Arya – but no backstory in program notes or choreography. The opening repeated itself: they walked past each other, then caught each other’s attention.  Alas, these leads had neither the same presence nor expressiveness of steps. There was a crowd again, but they seemed to take cues from the protagonists, sometimes imitating their movements, like with an odd detail where Boylston got on pointe in fifth and wiggled her hips. There were reaches and twists for the leads again, but if they looked dramatic, if thematically bare in the first section, here they devolved into repetitive walking, excessive leaning, and awkward straddles. The program notes claimed that "in a world fraught with loneliness and noise, their love becomes a sanctuary," but what we witnessed was perfunctory romance, barely an echo of the first couple's intensity. If this was love, who’d want it?

Scene from Serenade after Plato’s Symposium. Photo: Steven Pisano.

The evening’s challenges didn’t end at the bridge. Ratmansky’s ballet was another ambitious adaptation that, in a different way, offered potential and conundrums. The work purports to be an abstraction with intricate dance for seven talented male dancers, yet with so much richness in Plato's actual "Symposium" and in Leonard Bernstein's music, the disconnect between source material and stage realization quickly became frustrating. There was explosive jumping, inventive partnering and gestured phrasing, but no dancer was ever clearly identified. Who here was Socrates? Who was Aristophanes? The audience was left to guess. Amid a solid cast – Jake Roxander, Carlos Gonzalez and Jose Sebastian among them – no one really got to stand out and tell a story that made sense. When Sunmi Park finally appeared, so late that her entrance felt like an ending, we could at least identify her as Diotima. She commanded the stage and reduced the dynamic to reverential worship, obliterating whatever camaraderie and brotherly (or romantic) love the men might have shared.

Catherine Hurlin and Isaac Hernández in Theme and Variations. © The George Balanchine Trust. Photo: Steven Pisano.

Finally and blissfully came “Theme and Variations,” and with it a truly memorable, if uneven performance by Catherine Hurlin and Isaac Hernández. Her dancing revealed an internal debate: whether to emphasize Balanchine's neoclassical refinement or showcase her formidable technique and eloquent styling. The tension yielded some conflicting, though still beautiful, results. After a demure opening, she positively stormed into her turns with big arm reaches, impeccable speed, and intense focus on elegance. In the pas de deux, this focus became a slight detriment: the emphasis on refined movement and cultured feet left some punch missing. Hernández by comparison offered more even dancing throughout, solid and assured. There was great dancing from the rest of the cast too, particularly Sierra Armstrong, whose eloquent arabesques demonstrated the clarity Balanchine demands.

The evening thus offered a microcosm of the company's current identity: a group of talented dancers eager to champion new voices while anchoring itself in repertory cornerstones. Till we meet again, let's hope they get new choreography that wouldn't waste them.

copyright © 2025 by Marianne Adams

Read more

In Conversation With Dance

In Conversation With Dance


“Prelude: Discipline Is Freedom,” “Never Top 40 (Jukebox),” “Priestess Hill,” “Messages to the Storm”
Garth Fagan Dance
The Joyce Theater
New York, NY
November 5, 2026


For its 55th anniversary, Garth Fagan Dance staged a conversation across generations. Two older works by its founder, “Prelude: Discipline Is Freedom” and “Never Top 40 (Jukebox),” were paired with 2026 creations: “Priestess Hill” and “Messages to the Storm,” by Norwood ‘PJ’ Pennewell, the company’s Artistic Director, and Natalie Rogers-Cropper, its President,

By Marianne Adams
Build a Future On a Great Past

Build a Future On a Great Past


“Trio Élégiaque,” “Flight,” “The Dream”
American Ballet Theatre
David H. Koch Theater
New York, NY
October 31, 2026 (matinee)


The last program offered by American Ballet Theatre as part of its far too brief fall season took a risk by presenting the choreography of its young corps de ballet dancer, 21-year-old Brady Farrar, along with a trusted workhorse, Frederick Ashton’s “The Dream,” and an odd misfit of a solo by Jae Man Joo, “Flight.” The combination registered

By Marianne Adams
Old and New

Old and New


First program: "Airs", "Piazzola Caldera", "No Longer Silent"
Second program: "30 Incoming", "3 Epitaphs", "Tensile Involvement", "Piazzola Caldera"
Paul Taylor Dance Company
David H. Koch Theater
Lincoln Center
New York, NY
November 3, 2026 (first program) and November 5, 2026 (second program)


The two programs combined the old and the new, and a variety of styles with three of Taylor’s works—“3 Epitaphs”, “Airs”, and “Piazzolla Caldera”; one premiere, Lauren Lovette’s “30 Incoming”; and two new-to-the

By Mary Cargill
Love Stories

Love Stories


"Trio Élegiaque", "Flight", "The Dream"
American Ballet Theatre
David H. Koch Theater
New York, NY
October 28th and 30th, 2026


ABT’s program celebrated three different types of love stories, beginning with the premiere of the young corps dancer Brady Farrar’s “Trio Élégiaque”, with three couples weaving through Rachmaninoff’s music.  “Flight”, choreographed in 2012 by the South Korean choreographer Jae Man Joo, honored the love the audience had for Herman Cornejo, via Bach cello music, and 

By Mary Cargill