Physical Thinking

Physical Thinking
Heather Ogden and Jack Bertinshaw with Artists of the Ballet in "The Second Detail". Photo by Michael Slobodian. 

"The Vertiginous Thrill of Exactitude", "Approximate Sonata", "The Second Detail"
The National Ballet of Canada
Four Seasons Centre for the Performing Arts
Toronto, Canada
June 1, 2019


The National Ballet of Canada's latest triple bill was a whirlwind tour through William Forsythe's choreographic world. The program was short, clocking in at just over one hour of dance (excluding the intermission), yet dense with a variety of terpsichorean riches. The dancers really sunk their teeth into the three works, using them as opportunities to push the boundaries of movement and speed. The results were stirring and beautiful.  

The program opened with Forsythe's well-known "The Vertiginous Thrill of Exactitude", with Stephen Galloway's distinctive saucer-like lime green tutus, set to Franz Schubert's 9th Symphony. Of the three ballets, it is the one most grounded in classical vocabulary and style, with nods to Bournonville and Balanchine alike. Foundational ballet steps are very much present, but taken to new extremes. A lifted leg becomes a split, a jaunty petit allegro turns into rapid fire jumps, and energy extending through the fingertips transforms into flicked wrists. Unusual positions such as pliés en pointe highlight changes in height or levels. Newcomer Hannah Galway, who just joined the corps de ballet last year, filled in for Jillian Vanstone on opening night. She looked confident and brought attack and impressive extensions to her dancing.  Calley Skalnik fared well in her variation, playing with tempo and accents to bring out the nuances of the music. Chelsey Meiss kept up with the breakneck speed of the choreography but looked a bit frantic and unwieldy in the process. Naoya Ebe and Harrison James were both stellar in the male roles. Ebe is known for the height of his jumps and he created many virtuoso moments slicing through air. James brought precision and clarity to his movement, which are so important in this ballet, lest it become a muddled blur. "Vertiginous" is a gruelling, pure dance ballet, a sort of "Études" of its time. It is not a bad idea to bring it back into the repertoire every few years as a test and challenge. 

"Approximate Sonata", a series of five pas de deux danced by four pairs of dancers, is mellower in tone. It has been worked and re-worked over the years since its premiere with Ballet Frankfurt in 1996. The version seen here is the 2016 version that Forsythe set on the Paris Opera Ballet. The set is sparse with a sign reading “YES” (“Ja” in other versions) in the background, which fades in and out of view depending on the lighting. The partnering here is reciprocal, departing from the gendered norms of the classical paradigm. The ballerina is hardly passive. Both parties have agency, initiating and reacting in equal parts. The couples dance harmoniously, in opposition and independently alongside Thom Willems textured score. Sonia Rodriguez and Spencer Hack danced the 1st and 5th Sonatas, coming together and apart, tracing the negative space between their bodies with utmost control. The 2nd and 3rd Sonatas, with Hannah Fischer and Christopher Gerty, and Svetlana Lunkina and Félix Paquet respectively, are more confrontational. Tension is manifested in sparring gestures and resistance, as if moving through honey. The women are dressed in simple black leotards and then men in bright pink tops and blue pants, but in the 4th Sonata the woman (Tanya Howard) is set apart with neon green pants. The significance is unclear, but it is beside the point.

Naoya Ebe and Harrison James in "The Vertiginous Thrill of Exactitude." Photo by Karolina Kuras. 

The program closed with “The Second Detail”, created on the company in 1991. It is part of a full-length work, "The Loss of Small Detail", but often stands on its own. The music is a hypnotic piece by Forsythe’s frequent collaborator, Willems. There is a sign in this ballet too, with the word “THE” front and centre. Chairs line the back of the stage and the costumes designed by Forsythe feature sleek minimalist long sleeve grey leotards. A brilliant ensemble work, the ballet is non-stop, with dancers coming in and out of focus in solos, duets and groups without hierarchy. Intricate steps mingle joyously with walking and running. When on the sidelines, the dancers watch each other, mimicking a studio environment. At other times, they sat in the chairs, their port de bras making a quiet commentary like a Greek chorus. Unfortunately, Nan Wang suffered an injury in the middle of the performance, exiting the stage quickly.  The dancers looked understandably shaken for some time, before carrying on. Paquet took on some of Wang's part. The energy of the piece is daring yet cheeky and fun. Greta Hodgkinson, the only dancer of this cast who was in the company when Forsythe originally created this work, especially embodied this. In typical postmodern fashion, the work resists interpretation, although the pull to ask questions sometimes persists. When an enigmatic woman (Tanya Howard) enters in a structural white dress (a gorgeous design by Issey Miyake) and the group circles around her, one wonders who she is. The imagery calls to mind the chosen one in “Le Sacre du Printemps”. The choreography becomes wild and erratic, dancers darting across the stage. Before one can make much sense of it, the “THE” sign is kicked over and the show is over.

copyright © 2019 by Denise Sum

Read more

To Grow A Garden

To Grow A Garden


"The Sleeping Beauty"
New York City Ballet
David H. Koch Theater
New York, NY
February 13, 2026


Peter Martins’ 1991 production of “The Sleeping Beauty” returned to City Ballet for two well-sold weeks; it has remained basically unchanged for 25 years, with the same strengths and weaknesses.  Fortunately this performance, with Indiana Woodward and Chun Wai Chan as the royal couple and Ashley Laracey as the Lilac Fairy, and a number of debuts in supporting roles, was definitely on

By Mary Cargill
Kings and Dancers

Kings and Dancers


"Dig the Say", "This Bitter Earth", " "The Naked King", "Everywhere We Go"
New York City Ballet
David H. Koch Theater
New York, NY
February 5th and February 8th, 2026


Alexei Ratmansky’s new ballet “The Naked King”, a retelling of Hans Christian Andersen’s always timely “The Emperor Has No Clothes”, is another of his explorations of ballet’s history.  Shortly before he died Diaghilev had come up with the idea of using the Andersen story for a ballet,

By Mary Cargill
Fresh Takes

Fresh Takes


"Walpurgisnacht Ballet," "Flower Festival in Genzano Pas de Deux," "The Wind-Up," "Opus 19/The Dreamer"
New York City Ballet
David H. Koch Theater
New York, NY
January 30, 2026


On a night abundant with debuts, including an all-new second cast for Justin Peck’s “The Wind-Up” which premiered a day earlier, the real revelations came from the repertory. While Peck's latest work stumbled through familiar choreographic territory, the dancers once again proved that a company’s greatest asset is

By Marianne Adams
The Gods Are Smiling

The Gods Are Smiling


"Serenade", "The Prodigal Son", "Paquita"
New York City Ballet
David H. Koch Theater
New York, NY
January 31, 2026 matinee


The programming gods, who can sometimes be arbitrary, provided an outstanding triple bill, a perfect example of scheduling a complete meal.  It opened with “Serenade”, a most luscious appetizer, followed by the dramatic meat of “The Prodigal Son”, and ended with a fine dessert, the Spanish frivolity of Ratmansky’s take on the Grand Pas of Petipa’s “Paquita”

By Mary Cargill